Saturday, 16 August 2008

Football in the Olympics

An interesting article by Mike Florio on Sportingnews.com, proposes that Football (we'll refer to it as American Football for the purposes of this article) be made part of the Olympics. After watching all of 15 minutes of some kind of Swimming, it's hard not to agree that it would be a hell of a lot more exciting than watching that, or Ludo, or Scrabble, whichever event will make it into the Olympics for 2012.

However, I (and I say I because it's only my view, not Wide-Right's) am 100% against any such move, and here's why:

1) There are 16 days to play the required amount of games. That doesn't work in American Football. At best, you could play 3-4 games. You'd need a minimum of 5 (3 group games, a semi final, and a final) to make it work. Until that is possible, keep dreaming.

2) That time frame would also preclude any Professional from taking part. The risk in sending a player over for 1-2 games every 4 years would make most coaches balk, so imagine what playing a dramatically increased schedule would do? No, you'd be looking at amateur/college players to make it work. Then once you say that, you'd be eliminating the top tier of players in the rest of the world. A Catch 22 situation and a half.

3) The Olympics should be the pinnacle of your sporting career - not a nice trip and a chance to add a gold medal to your millions of dollars. Football (the one with feet) is in the Olympics, and in truth nobody cares. People are excited that the new Premiership season starts today, but the Olympics generally passes by a lot of people - and that has pro's in it.

4) Fourthly - and most importantly - is that the competition factor would be zero. I'll dwell on that point in a second, after some choice words from the original article:

The question becomes whether the sport can grow beyond our borders to the point that inclusion in the Olympics becomes a no-brainer proposition. Its ability to do so depends in large part on the ability of the NFL to export regular-season contests to other countries. Hopefully, the next collective bargaining agreement will expand the regular season to 17 or 18 games, creating ample opportunities to send games that count to other countries.

- Mike Florio, Sportingnews.com

That the NFL wants to expand is undoubted. However, the idea that this can be achieved via simply showing people the product on offer is laughable. Why do sales of Tennis Rackets pick up when Wimbledon is on? Why do people start playing Golf as soon as the Masters hits our screens every year? The answer is because the infrastructures are in place to allow young kids to play these sports both casually and competitively, regardless of age.

The NFL - and most commentators - seem to be missing the point completely. If I wanted to play American Football, even as a die hard fan who is obsessed, I'd have no way of doing so, and wouldn't really know where to begin. The sport is not available to schools, which limits the amount of players at it's most basic level. I played Basketball at school, and it generated both ability and interest in the sport.

The sport needs funding at the very fundamental level before this idea could even get past the 'Idiot with a soapbox' phase that it is in now. How about instead of putting money into trying to convince the IOC to accept the sport, give youngsters a chance to play football from the age of 7-8, like kids in America. The natural talent pool exists around the world, it's just that for most kids who grow up with a football at their feet rather than in their hands, their dreams lie in the back of the net, rather than the end zone.

Until that grass-roots funding and support is in place, you can forget about the idea of American Football as an Olympic sport.

Thursday, 14 August 2008

Lynch to the Pats?

What was it we said a couple of weeks ago about Lynch joining the Patriots?

ESPN have today reported that the Patriots are interested in signing John Lynch as long as he passes a physical.

We believe that Lynch would likely play in packages suited to his strengths, and be used as a role model to bring along the young defence. ESPN also point out that Belichick is "the best at figuring out ways to use veterans and not wear them out."

Tuesday, 12 August 2008

Seattle have zero receivers

Bobby Engram (97 receptions last year) is the latest Seahawk to hit the injury trail, following Deion Branch's long-term recovery from his surgically repaired knee. Engram has cracked a bone in his right shoulder, and is out 6-8 weeks, meaning his first game back could be the week 4 match-up with the Giants.

This means the starting spots at the receiving corps, along with Nate Burleson, will be between second-year Courtney Taylor and third-year veteran Ben Obomanu, with undrafted free agent Michael Bumpus from Washington State and former practice squad player Logan Payne fighting to be the 4th receiver until Branch and/or Engram prove their fitness.

Pennington a 'Phin

Following last weeks' signing by the Jets of Brett Favre, Chad Pennington was released - after being linked to the Vikings and Dolphins, Miami (And Bill Parcells, the Head Coach who drafted Pennington) took the plunge meaning week one is the AFC East Divisional match-up between the Jets and the Dolphins.

This says an awful lot about Tony Sparano/Bill Parcells' belief in both John Beck and Josh McCown - if Beck isn't ready after a year of learning the playbook, and McCown hasn't impressed, then it really is out with the old in South Florida.

Friday, 8 August 2008

Chris Williams out for the year?

Rumours are abound in Chicago that Rookie Chris Williams, the 14th overall pick in this year's draft, is out for the entire 2008 season with a back injury.

Williams is yet to practice with the team, and yesterday underwent surgery to repair a herniated disc in his back. Although he is still on the 53 man roster, it is expected that he will be placed on IR before the season begins. The Bears have shown interest in re-signing veteran tackle Fred Miller, who was cut at the end of last season.

In our opinion, Williams - although a great finesse blocker - was a risk at 14. The reason he fell so far was simply because of injury concerns, and even though you never know for sure whether those injury worries wll hamper someone through a long, physical career, it is telling that the two players in this year's draft with such concerns (Williams and Chiefs DT Glenn Dorsey) have both yet to contribute meaningfully because of injury.

Thursday, 7 August 2008

Brett Favre IS a Jet

I think this is all that needs to be said:

Current terms emanating from ESPN are that it's a 4th rounder that could rise to a 1st rounder if Favre undertakes 80% of the snaps and the Jets reach the Super Bowl.

Wednesday, 6 August 2008

Rookie Torain out 6-8 weeks

Broncos 5th round pick Ryan Torain will be out six to eight weeks after suffering a broken elbow in practice on Wednesday morning.

Reports this morning said he was down for several minutes after being tackled by Nate Webster and Jamie Winborn in 9-on-7 drills.

The injury should make Selvin Young's starting job a safer bet.